Dental Implants vs. Dentures: Pros, Cons and What’s Best For You

BY TOFTWOOD DENTAL PRACTICE

27 November 2025

When comparing dental implants vs dentures, it’s normal to feel unsure about which option is right for you. Both treatments provide effective tooth replacement solutions, but they differ in cost, procedure, longevity, comfort, and suitability. Understanding these differences can help you make a confident, informed decision about your smile and long-term oral health.

At Toftwood Dental Practice, we support patients across Norfolk who are considering dental implants, dentures and other restorative options.

Treatment Process

Here’s a quick overview of each treatment to help you understand how both options work:

Dental implants involve placing a small titanium screw into the jawbone, where it acts like an artificial tooth root. Once this has fused with the bone (a process called osseointegration), a crown, bridge or denture can be attached on top. The step-by-step process typically includes:

Assessment – Your dentist checks your oral health, gums and bone density.

Implant placement – The implant is placed into the jaw during a minor surgical procedure under local anaesthetic.

Healing phase – The area is left to heal for several months so the implant can bond with the bone.
Restoration – A custom-made crown, bridge or implant-supported denture is fitted to complete your new smile.

Dentures are removable replacement teeth. The NHS describes two main types:

Complete dentures – For people missing all teeth.

Partial dentures – For those missing some teeth.

The process usually includes taking impressions. Next, models are tried in to check the fit. Then, your dentist makes any necessary adjustments before fitting the final dentures. Because no surgery is required, dentures are suitable for many patients, including those who may not be able to have implants due to low bone density, medical conditions, or personal preference.

Lifespan

Both dental implants and dentures can offer long-term solutions for missing teeth, but their lifespan and maintenance needs differ.

Dental implants

Designed to be long-lasting and, according to the NHS, can last many years or even decades with good oral hygiene.

The implant itself is highly durable, but the attached crown, bridge or denture may need replacing over time because of normal wear.

Their longevity also depends on factors like gum health, smoking habits and regular dental check-ups.

Dentures

Typically last around 5–7 years, although this varies depending on changes in your jawbone and daily wear.

Over time, natural bone shrinkage can affect how well they fit, meaning relining or replacement may be needed.

Proper care and cleaning can help extend their lifespan and maintain comfort.

Considering a long-term solution?

Book a consultation at Toftwood Dental Practice to discuss durable options tailored to your needs.

Dentist in Dereham

Are you looking for a dentist in Dereham?

Book Appointment

Comfort

Comfort levels can differ widely between dentures vs implants.

Dental implants, once healed, often feel very similar to natural teeth because they are fixed directly into the jawbone. They don’t shift, move, or rely on adhesives, which can help many people feel more confident when eating and speaking. For most patients, they gradually become part of their normal day-to-day routine.

Dentures may take longer to get used to. Some patients experience gum irritation, slight movement when speaking or eating, or changes in fit over time as the jawbone naturally shrinks. Well-fitted dentures can be comfortable and effective, but they may need occasional adjustments to maintain a good fit.

Aesthetics

Both treatments can provide natural-looking results, but they differ in how they support your smile and facial appearance.

Implants: Custom crowns are made to match your natural teeth in colour, shape, and size so they blend in seamlessly with your smile. Implants provide a natural look because they mimic both the root and visible part of the tooth.

Dentures: Modern dentures are more realistic than ever, with lifelike tooth shades and gums designed to suit your features. They can restore fullness to the cheeks and lips, but as the jawbone changes, they may need adjusting or replacing to stay comfortable and natural-looking.

Affordability

Affordability is an important consideration when comparing implants vs dentures.

Dental implants are usually more expensive because of the surgical procedure, the high-quality materials and the multi-step process involved. Costs can vary depending on how many teeth need replacing, whether you need additional treatments like bone grafting, and the type of restoration used (such as a single crown or a full arch).

Dentures are generally more affordable and often have a lower upfront cost. They can be a cost-effective way to replace several or all teeth without surgery and come in different materials and designs to suit various budgets.

However, because implants last longer and help maintain bone structure, they may offer better long-term value, especially if they reduce the need for frequent replacements or adjustments.

For personalised guidance and clear financial options on dental implants in Norfolk or dentures in Toftwood, we can create a tailored treatment plan that aligns with your goals, oral health needs and budget.

Aftercare

Proper aftercare plays an important role in keeping your new smile healthy and comfortable.

Dental implants: good oral hygiene is essential for keeping dental implants healthy and long-lasting. Implants need the same care as natural teeth:

Brush twice a day with fluoride toothpaste, paying attention to the gumline around the implant.
Clean between the teeth and around the implant daily with floss or interdental brushes.
Attend regular check-ups and hygiene appointments.
Avoid smoking, as it can slow healing and increase the risk of implant failure.

Dentures: caring for dentures properly helps keep your mouth healthy and your dentures comfortable for longer:

Remove and clean your dentures daily with a soft brush and non-abrasive cleaner.

Soak them overnight in a suitable denture solution or plain water to prevent warping.

Gently clean your gums, tongue and any remaining teeth every day to reduce plaque and irritation.

Attend regular check-ups so your dentist can review the fit, make adjustments if needed and check the health of your mouth.

Before and After - dental implant, smile close up from the side.

Before and after dental implant, open mouth close up

Before and after dental implant, mouth close up from the side

Pain and Recovery

Recovery differs between tooth replacement options, so it’s helpful to understand what to expect with each one:

Implants involve a surgical procedure, so some discomfort, swelling, or bruising is expected in the first few days. This is usually manageable with over-the-counter pain relief and following your dentist’s aftercare instructions. Most people return to normal activities quite quickly, but full healing and integration with the bone can take several months before the final restoration is fitted.

Dentures involve no surgery, so recovery time is usually shorter. However, it can take a few weeks to fully adapt. Some patients experience temporary soreness, increased saliva, slight speech changes, or difficulty eating certain foods at first. These issues usually improve as you get used to the dentures and after any small adjustments to the fit.

Pros and Cons of Dental Implants vs Dentures

Potential side effects of dental implants can include issues such as infection, implant loosening or failure, and gum or bone complications, which your dentist will discuss with you before treatment.

Treatment	Pros	Cons
Dental Implants	Long-lasting solution, fixed, stable and natural-feeling, helps maintain jawbone density, and no movement during eating or speaking.	Higher upfront cost, requires surgery, not suitable for all patients, and healing time can take months.
Dentures	More affordable, no surgery required, suitable for many patients; and quick to produce and fit.	May become loose over time, can cause gum irritation, may affect speech or eating, and needs periodic replacement or adjustments

Final Thoughts: What Option Is Best for You?

Choosing between dentures vs implants ultimately depends on your oral health, lifestyle, budget and long-term goals.

Dental implants are often preferred by people who want a permanent, natural-feeling replacement and are suitable for surgery. Dentures remain an excellent, cost-effective and non-invasive alternative.

The best way to know what’s right for you is through a professional assessment. At Toftwood Dental Practice, we help patients across Dereham and Norfolk explore both treatments with clarity and confidence.

Book a consultation today to discover whether dental implants or dentures are the best fit for your smile.

FAQs

How do eating and speaking differ with implants vs. dentures?

Implants function similarly to natural teeth, so chewing and speaking often feel more natural. Dentures can sometimes move slightly, especially lower dentures, which may take time to adapt to.

Are dentures or implants better for the elderly?

Both options can be suitable. Many older adults successfully receive implants, but bone health, medical history, and medication use must be considered. Dentures may be more appropriate for patients who prefer a non-surgical option.

What’s better for one missing tooth — a single-tooth denture or implant?

A single implant provides a long-lasting, natural-feeling replacement without affecting neighbouring teeth. A single-tooth denture can be a quicker, more affordable option but may feel less stable.

Can I switch from dentures to implants later on?

Yes, many patients transition from dentures to implants. However, prolonged denture use can lead to bone loss, which may require bone grafting before implant placement.

This content is for informational purposes only. Consult a professional for personal advice.

Sources:

NHS (National Health Service – UK)